ICE and HSI worksite enforcement activities strike again – this time it’s temp agencies!

In an ICE Press Release today, it was announced that during an ICE and HSI investigation, it was found that a 2-location temp agency was knowingly supplying undocumented unskilled and skilled warehouse and janitorial workers to their clients as a part of their labor pool.

Clinton Roy Perkins, the owner of Can Do It Inc. in Bensenville, IL, was sentenced on February 16th to 18 months in prison, to be followed by three years of supervised release, for knowingly hiring illegal aliens at the staffing companies. He pleaded guilty in September 2010. On Feb. 25th, U.S. District Judge Joan B. Gottschall also ordered the forfeiture of $465,178 in proceeds obtained as a result of the criminal activity.

Perkins admitted to knowingly hiring more than 10 illegal aliens from Mexico between October 2006 and October 2007.  Perkins did not require the workers to provide documents establishing their immigration status or lawful right to work in the United States.

Perkins and his son-in-law, Chrispher Reindl, paid the illegal workers’ wages in cash; did not deduct payroll taxes or other withholdings. Perkins and Reindl directed low-level supervisory employees to transport illegal workers back and forth between locations near the aliens’ residences in Chicago and work sites in the suburbs. Both also provided bogus six-digit numbers – purporting to be the last six digits of the aliens’ Social Security numbers – to a company, knowing that their workers were in the country illegally and did not possess valid Social Security numbers.

In a quote from special agent in charge of ICE HSI in Chicago:  “We will hold employers accountable for their actions.  Mr. Perkins knowingly hired an illegal workforce and circumvented our nation’s immigration laws for financial gain. The goal of our enforcement efforts is two-fold – reduce the demand for illegal employment and protect job opportunities for the nation’s lawful workforce.”

ICE was assisted in the investigation by the U.S. Department of Labor’s Office of Inspector General in Chicago. Assistant U.S. Attorneys Christopher R. McFadden and Daniel May, Northern District of Illinois, prosecuted the case.

One of Mississippi’s most successful and largest private employers pled guilty in federal court last week to knowingly violating federal criminal conspiracy laws in its employment of illegal aliens at the company’s electrical transformer plant in Laurel, MS following an investigation by ICE and Homeland Security Investigations (HSI).  The company agreed to pay a $2.5 million fine, which is larger than normal for such a conviction, the U.S. Justice Department said in a news release.

Immigration agents detained more than 600 illegal immigrants at Howard Industries’ electrical transformer plant during a massive raid on Aug. 25, 2008. Those detained in the raid came from countries including Brazil, El Salvador, Germany, Guatemala, Honduras, Mexico, Panama and Peru, and most of them were deported, though a few were convicted on identity theft charges for using fraudulent documents and providing fake papers to other workers.

The company said in a statement that it was pleased to resolve the investigation “based on the actions of its former human resources manager Jose Humberto Gonzalez.”  Gonzalez is the only company executive who has been charged in the case. He pled guilty in December 2009 to conspiracy and admitted that he hired hundreds of people who he knew were in the country illegally.  

The company had repeatedly denied allegations that it had knowingly hired individuals without work authorization, putting all of the blame on its HR manager, Jose Humberto Gonzalez, who was charged in a 25-count indictment with conspiracy and employee verification fraud.   He faces a maximum of 5 years of imprisonment on the conspiracy charge and on each employee verification fraud count. He also faces a minimum of 2 years imprisonment for the aggravated identity theft charge and possible fines up to $250,000.

Howard Industries was charged with knowingly and willfully conspiring to encourage and induce undocumented workers to reside in the US, and knowingly conspiring to conceal, harbor and shield from detection such workers.  As it turned out, Howard Industries waived indictment and agreed to plead guilty to the one-count felony of  conspiracy to commit offense or to defraud the United States which calls for a term of not less than one and not more than 5 years of probation and a fine of up to $500,000. However, this fine was substantially enhanced to $2.5 million due to the nature of the crime (harboring), the number of workers involved (100 or more), and the size of the company.

Apparently Gonzalez would routinely hire unauthorized workers who presented false identity documents, including green-cards and Social Security cards, and then would complete the I-9 with the fake information.  Gonzalez was also accused of submitting SSNs to the Social Security Administration to verify their numbers and then disregarding the results if they came back as invalid.

E-Verify doesn’t protect against identify fraud: Howard Industries was using E-Verify and ran every applicant through the system, but E-Verify doesn’t detect identify fraud and shouldn’t be used as a substitute for I-9 compliance.  The case at hand teaches a lesson about the E-Verify program, in that using E-Verify doesn’t insulate an employer against penalties and doesn’t provide a safe harbor against worksite enforcement.

So what’s an employer to do?

If you are contemplating ‘going electronic’, whether that be an electronic I-9 system or enrolling in the E-Verify program, it is imperative that you find out what condition your I-9’s are in.  This is done by having a qualified immigration attorney that specializes in compliance issues perform either a partial or full audit on your I-9’s so that the reoccurring errors and violations buried in your paperwork can be identified, corrected, and your staff properly trained.  We additionally encourage our clients to work with us in establishing policies and guidelines as to how they want to process and manage the I-9 function at their organization and document this, and make sure that everyone involved with the process is trained and fully understands your internal policies.

We link to the ICE press release

For more information on our employer compliance services and solutions

February 16, 2011, Brett Dreyer, Chief of the Worksite Enforcement, Unit of Homeland Security Investigations, verified on 2/16/2011 that ICE continues to focus its investigations both on businesses that were brought to their attention by tips and leads, and on those that work in areas of national security and critical infrastructure. Mr. Dreyer further confirmed: “The agency continues to be interested in egregious employers as they tend to break other laws in addition to immigration…including paying employees under the table, avoiding taxes and ignoring employee protections. The inspections will touch on employers of all sizes and in every state in the nation — no one industry is being targeted nor is any one industry immune from scrutiny.”

Confirmation has been publicized that NOI’s were indeed served throughout the USA on February 17^th.  The audits are expected to be completed within the next 2-3 months. We link here for more on this story.

This is a good time to review what you should do if you are served with a Notice of Inspection (NOI):

• Immediately contact Immigration Solutions and company management
• Employers are allowed by law 3 days notice to respond by producing the I-9 records of their active as well as terminated employees within a particular period of time

The NOI will be most probably be accompanied by a very invasive Document Subpoena that might ask for all of some of the below items:  

• A copy of your I-9 Policy and Procedures Statement or Manual
• I-9 forms for current employees hired after 11/6/1986
• I-9 forms for terminated employees within the required retention period
• Complete employee lists of current and terminated employees
• Quarterly Wage and hour reports
• Payroll Summaries
• SSA Mismatch correspondence
• E-Verify and/or SSNVS documents
• Business information such as:  Employer ID number, owner’s SSN/address, business license, etc.

We work with our clients to create compliant workforces, and now is the time to be proactive if you absolutely know that you have problems with your I-9 forms; and, by the way, most employers do.  We encourage you to be proactive and take action now before you pay the high price of being put in a position where your options have diminished.

We are happy to hear from you and are very flexible with our package of compliance services and solutions.  Our talented team is read to assist you with whatever you’d like to accomplish with your compliance programs.  Visit our I-9 Resource Center here.

Last week the House subcommittee on immigration policy and enforcement held their first hearing on “ICE Worksite Enforcement – Up to the Job?” The major agenda item was whether or not Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) was adequately enforcing worksite immigration laws.  The Republican members called upon ;their usual sources to diminish the Obama administration’s enforcement efforts, even though Deputy Director of ICE, Kumar Kibble stated quite clearly that ICE has achieved record numbers of investigations, audits, fines, and deportations by citing the below  statistics.  Frankly, after listening to the majority members, one can’t help but wonder if any amount of enforcement would be sufficient to meet their expectations.

Under the Obama administration, ICE has moved  away from raids, and stepped  up the pace of auditing businesses who may be suspect to employing undocumented workers.  However, the emphasis today is more on employers who hire immigrants and not just arresting undocumented immigrants who are working in the factories, the hotels, restaurants and construction businesses.  The vehicle being used to police the workforce is the auditing of I-9 forms,  levying fines and utilizing employer verification tools such as E-Verify and the Ice Mutual Agreement Between the Government and Employers Program.

The Deputy Director cited the following statistics as evidence of the success of ICE’s worksite enforcement: for FY 2010:

• A record 2,746 worksite enforcement investigations, more than doubling the 1,191 cases initiated in FY 2008.
• ICE criminally arrested 196 employers for worksite related violation, surpassing the previous high of 135 in FY 2008.
• ICE also issued a record 2,196 notices of inspection to employers, surpassing the prior year’s record of 1,444 and more than quadrupling the 503 inspections in 2008.
• ICE issued 237 final orders – documents requiring employers to cease violation the law and directing them to pay fines – totaling $6,956,026, compared to the 18 issued for $675,209 in FY 2008.
• The total of $6,956,026 last year represents the most final orders issued since the creation of ICE in 2003.
• In addition worksite investigations resulted in a record $36,611,320 in judicial fines, forfeitures, and restitutions.
• Finally ice brought a new level of integrity to the contracting process by debarring a record 97 businesses and 49 individuals preventing unscrupulous companies from engaging in future business with the government.

The glaring facts that came out of the hearing are that no matter whether it’s worksite raids or company audits with deportations of undocumented aliens, the current state of how foreign born workers are processed into the country is no longer working.  The conversation that we all should be having is the comprehensive reform of how workers are brought into the USA.  We can only hope that the GOP and the Democrats can have civil and reasonable debate that results in meaningful change.  Let’s see what happens.

Following through on a campaign promise, Florida Governor Rick Scott signed four executive orders minutes after being sworn in, including one that requires all state agencies to use E-Verify, making it the first state to mandate E-Verify participation in 2011.  Florida joins a list of 13 other states that have mandatory E-Verify laws or executive orders in place.

According to a press release  from the governor’s office:

Executive Order No. 11-02 requires state agencies to use the E-Verify system to verify employment eligibility of state employees and contractors.

• All state agencies under the direction of the Governor must use the E-Verify system to check employment eligibility of their current and prospective employees.
• Requires state agencies under the direction of the Governor to include in all state contracts a requirement that contractors utilize the E-Verify system to verify the employment eligibility of:
  • all persons employed during the contract term by the contractor to perform employment duties within Florida; and
  • all persons (including subcontractors) assigned by the contractor to perform work pursuant to the contract with the state agency…

The Florida State Legislature, which convenes next week, is also expected to consider an Arizona-style immigration enforcement bill that would also require all employers in the state to use E-Verify. The bills are being drafted by Rep. Bill Snyder and Sen. Mike Bennett.  This is fast approaching the Arizona question again… Can the state trump the federal government on immigration requirements?

It is worth noting that, Rhode Island’s Governor, Lincoln Chafee, rescinded Rhode Island Executive Order 08-01 that required the state as well as contractors and vendors doing business with Rhode Island to register and use E-Verify for all new hires. Chafee called the use of E-Verify a “divisive issue.”

So, what does this mean going forward for Florida’s State Agencies and employers, in general? 

Prior to enrolling in E-Verify, you must undergo comprehensive I-9 training by skilled immigration counsel that maintains an active employer compliance practice so that your designated E-verify employees have a solid grounding in the law as it relates to the I-9 form and today’s complex issues concerning employment eligibility verification.  The most well intentioned employees make mistakes and, if you’re like most employers, 30-50% of your I-9 forms may have issues that put you at risk. Half of the companies audited by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) get fined $110,000 or more.

Employers must recognize that this can mean civil and criminal liability to both themselves and their employers for charging untrained and inexperienced employees with the employment verification process.

You’re probably thinking …this could never happen to me and my company…we’ve reviewed our I-9 forms, done a self-audit and put policies in place for the management of our employment verification program.  This thinking is understandable; however, untrained HR managers and assistants that try to correct or minimize their mistakes to save their jobs can lead to charges of document falsification, perjury and tampering. 

Plainly put, this complicated one-page, poorly designed I-9 form has a 70-page government instruction manual!  Performing a self-audit, with an untrained staff, can likely increase the possibility for penalties and fines.

Please have a look at our I-9 Employer Resource Center:  www.I-9Audits.com , contact our office to discuss your concerns and sign up to receive our news and information.

Further to our series on site visits for the purposes of administrative, benefit and compliance reviews – we’ll look closer at FDNS areas of oversight…

What does FDNS Do?

FDNS officers resolve background check information and other concerns that surface during the processing of immigration benefit applications and petitions.  Resolution often requires communication with law enforcement or intelligence agencies to make sure that the information is relevant to the applicant or petitioner at hand and, if so, whether the information would have an impact on eligibility for the benefit.  

FDNS officers also perform checks of USCIS databases and public information, as well as other administrative inquiries, to verify information provided on, and in support of, applications and petitions.  Administrative inquiries may include:

•  Performance of fraud assessments – FDNS officers engage in fraud assessments (including Benefit Fraud and Compliance Assessments) to determine the types and volumes of fraud in certain immigration benefits programs;
• Compliance Reviews – Systematic reviews of certain types of applications or petitions to ensure the integrity of the immigration benefits system, and
• Targeted site visits – Inquiries conducted in cases where fraud is suspected.

FDNS uses the Fraud Detection and National Security Data System (FDNS-DS) to identify fraud and track potential patterns. 

USCIS has formed a partnership with ICE, in which FDNS pursues administrative inquiries into most application and petition fraud, while ICE conducts criminal investigations into major fraud conspiracies. 

Additional FDNS Functions

FDNS also conducts Benefit Fraud and Compliance Assessments to identify the types and volumes of fraud and develop mitigation strategies to deter and disrupt fraud.

What is the ASVVP and what does it do?

In July 2009, FDNS implemented the Administrative Site Visit and Verification Program (ASVVP) to conduct unannounced site inspections to verify information contained in certain visa petitions.  USCIS provides petitioners and their representatives of record (if any) an opportunity to review and address the information before denying or revoking an approved petition based on information obtained during a site inspection.

:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

Immigration Solutions always welcomes your feedback.  If you are interested in becoming a client of our office, please contact us at 562 612.3996 and request a consultation. We handle a broad range of business related immigration matters and have an active employer compliance practice, consulting on proper I-9 (Employment Eligibility Verification) best practices, auditing, training, and guiding our clients in achieving compliant immigration policies and procedures.  

Visit our new I-9 Employer Resource center here

We reference below what’s new with E-Verify for those of our readers who are enrolled in the system.

E-Verify Has Expanded Photo Matching!

E-Verify has launched a new U.S. Passport photo matching capability. Employers using E-Verify can now view photos to help confirm the validity of identity documents. Available documents include:

U.S. Passports and Passport Cards

• Permanent Resident Cards (Green Cards)
• Employment Authorization Documents

Visit here for more information about Photo Matching.

Did You Hear About the I E-Verify Seal?

Employers who use E-Verify can now prominently display the official I E-Verify™ seal at their workplace—on bulletin boards, doors or windows. E-Verify enrollees who would like a seal can send a request to uscis.verlogo@dhs.gov.

Designated Agents Get a New Name

The name “E-Verify Employer Agent” has replaced “Designated Agent” to refer to businesses that use E-Verify to confirm the employment eligibility of another company’s employees.

Puerto Rico Birth Certificate Guidance

On July 1, 2010, the Vital Statistics Office of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico began issuing new, more secure, certified copies of birth certificates to U.S. citizens born in Puerto Rico. After Oct. 30, 2010, all certified copies of birth certificates issued prior to July 1, 2010, became invalid. This new law does not affect the U.S. citizenship status of individuals born in Puerto Rico. It only affects the validity of certified copies of Puerto Rico birth certificates. See the USCIS Update for more information.

New on the E-Verify Website

Updated Manuals are now available

The latest E-Verify guidance can be easily downloaded or viewed online. E-Verify User Manuals, Quick Reference and Supplemental Guides for Employers, Federal Contractors, and E-Verify Employer Agents (formally Designated Agents) were all updated in September and are available on the Publications web page.

How Well is E-Verify Performing?

E-Verify recently updated the Statistics and Reports page on the web site. The updated statistics are based on E-Verify cases in Fiscal Year 2009 (October 2008 through September 2009).

History and Milestones

Check out the history of E-Verify—from the original legislation (1986 Immigration Reform and Control Act) to present-day major milestones. Visit the updated History and Milestones web page for more information.

E-Verify Outreach

E-Verify Offers Free Webinars!  Go to the E-Verify website and click on Sign Up for a Webinar for a complete schedule.

E-Verify Overview

• E-Verify for Existing Users
• E-Verify for Federal Contractors
• Form I-9, Employment Eligibility Verification

E-Verify gives live presentations and workshops, and participates in conferences and exhibits. If you would like a speaker for an event or conference, please e-mail us at E-Verify@dhs.gov or call 1-888-464-4218.

E-Verify in the Community

• Small, Minority, Women and Veterans Business Owners
  San Antonio, Texas                December 8, 2010
• 29th Annual Government Contract Management Conference
  Arlington, Virginia                    December 9-10, 2010
• The Agriculture Employer Forum
  Provo, Utah                             December 15, 2010
• The West Valley Chamber of Commerce
  Salt Lake City, Utah                December 16, 2010
• Human Resource Council of the Manufacturers Association of Central New York
  Syracuse, New York               December 21, 2010

Here’s the link to the new E-Verify Newsletter

Dec. 13, 2010:  US Attorney Thomas E. Delahanty II of the District of Main, announced that George Valvanis pled guilty to one count of engaging in a pattern or practice of recruiting or hiring illegal aliens unauthorized to work in the United States, and to one count of using a false attestation in an immigration document. The case was investigated by ICE and  Homeland Security Investigations (HSI).

According to court records, Valvanis managed several Dunkin’ Donuts stores located in the Portland area. Between 2001 and 2009, he knowingly employed 18 illegal aliens to work in his stores. Valvanis faces a maximum prison term of five years on the false attestation charge and six months on the alien hiring charge.

Dunkin’ Donuts Manager, in conspiracy, knew that the employees were unauthorized to work in the U.S, and falsely attested on the I-9 that they had examined the documents presented, and the documents appeared to be genuine and that the employees were eligible to work in the U.S

“ICE HSI will hold employers who knowingly hire an illegal workforce accountable for their actions,” said Bruce M. Foucart, special agent in charge of ICE HSI in Boston. Foucart oversees ICE HSI throughout New England. “Our office will continue to investigate and find employers who flout our laws and hire illegal labor, in order to reduce the demand for illegal employment and protect employment opportunities for the nation’s lawful workforce. ICE HSI will use enforcement tools, civil and criminal, when appropriate to bring about compliance.”

It is common knowledge that the U.S. government has been performing widespread investigations and audits of employers cracking down on the employment of undocumented workers.  Immigration and Customs Enforcement (“ICE”) recently reported record-breaking figures citing the highest deportation numbers and the most employer audits in our nation’s history.

Because of this, employer compliance is becoming more complex and enforcement activities are increasing at a record rate. The days of thinking that immigration enforcement is only targeting industries that employ a diverse workforce, such as health care, hospitality, restaurant, garment and the construction business, are long gone. Every employer must be aware of immigration laws as they relate to the processing and management of their I-9 forms and other compliance programs.  Many audits have resulted in fines for well known and respectable employers, large organizations and those that employ foreign workers, as well as small businesses that unintentionally filled out I-9 forms incorrectly.  Document mistakes – missing signatures, dates, over-documentation problems on I-9’s, have resulted in fines from $110 to $1,100 per mistake.

A recent examples of an I-9 document violation is a Colorado restaurant franchise that was fined $32K after an ICE inspection – not for hiring any illegal workers, but for I-9 document errors.

Chipotle Restaurant chain in Minnesota has recently been in the news for hiring illegal employees.  Pursuant to an ICE I-9 audit, Chipotle was forced to terminate some 50 workers.  There appears to be widespread I-9 restaurant investigations taking place in Minnesota.  Other restaurant chains in the area such as McDonald’s and Sizzler are concerned and have begun to proactively look into E-verify, the Internet-based system operated by USCIS in partnership with the Social Security Administration (SSA) that is free to employers and available in all 50 states.

The key to I-9 compliance for most organizations starts with a thorough self-examination of existing paper I-9’s, E-Verify submissions (if applicable), standard operating procedures, and past practices.   It is recommended that you consult with a licensed immigration or employment attorney who is knowledgeable in the practice of  employer compliance, specifically I-9 audits, training and policy development that can possibly save you thousands of dollars in fines and penalties.

Visit our new I-9 Employer Resource Center for helpful information and for our services and solutions.

USCIS has posted an Executive Summary of a listening session it hosted on November 2, 2010 regarding the Form I-9. The summary presents stakeholder comments, suggestions and concerns for how to improve the form itself and the overall I-9 process. There were many worthwhile suggestions that we hope USCIS will strongly consider.

In this climate of excessive worksite enforcement, we note that there was particular emphasis on USCIS providing better, more clear I-9 employer tools and support. Employers were also confused as to how to correct the I-9 form and who corrects what (which is covered in audits and training performed by qualified attorneys skilled in the area of employer compliance).

Should you wish to discuss your compliance concerns and issues, please contact our office. We also have an excellent employer compliance resource center that you can access at www.I-9Audits.com.