ICE and HSI worksite enforcement activities strike again – this time it’s temp agencies!

In an ICE Press Release today, it was announced that during an ICE and HSI investigation, it was found that a 2-location temp agency was knowingly supplying undocumented unskilled and skilled warehouse and janitorial workers to their clients as a part of their labor pool.

Clinton Roy Perkins, the owner of Can Do It Inc. in Bensenville, IL, was sentenced on February 16th to 18 months in prison, to be followed by three years of supervised release, for knowingly hiring illegal aliens at the staffing companies. He pleaded guilty in September 2010. On Feb. 25th, U.S. District Judge Joan B. Gottschall also ordered the forfeiture of $465,178 in proceeds obtained as a result of the criminal activity.

Perkins admitted to knowingly hiring more than 10 illegal aliens from Mexico between October 2006 and October 2007.  Perkins did not require the workers to provide documents establishing their immigration status or lawful right to work in the United States.

Perkins and his son-in-law, Chrispher Reindl, paid the illegal workers’ wages in cash; did not deduct payroll taxes or other withholdings. Perkins and Reindl directed low-level supervisory employees to transport illegal workers back and forth between locations near the aliens’ residences in Chicago and work sites in the suburbs. Both also provided bogus six-digit numbers – purporting to be the last six digits of the aliens’ Social Security numbers – to a company, knowing that their workers were in the country illegally and did not possess valid Social Security numbers.

In a quote from special agent in charge of ICE HSI in Chicago:  “We will hold employers accountable for their actions.  Mr. Perkins knowingly hired an illegal workforce and circumvented our nation’s immigration laws for financial gain. The goal of our enforcement efforts is two-fold – reduce the demand for illegal employment and protect job opportunities for the nation’s lawful workforce.”

ICE was assisted in the investigation by the U.S. Department of Labor’s Office of Inspector General in Chicago. Assistant U.S. Attorneys Christopher R. McFadden and Daniel May, Northern District of Illinois, prosecuted the case.

February 16, 2011, Brett Dreyer, Chief of the Worksite Enforcement, Unit of Homeland Security Investigations, verified on 2/16/2011 that ICE continues to focus its investigations both on businesses that were brought to their attention by tips and leads, and on those that work in areas of national security and critical infrastructure. Mr. Dreyer further confirmed: “The agency continues to be interested in egregious employers as they tend to break other laws in addition to immigration…including paying employees under the table, avoiding taxes and ignoring employee protections. The inspections will touch on employers of all sizes and in every state in the nation — no one industry is being targeted nor is any one industry immune from scrutiny.”

Confirmation has been publicized that NOI’s were indeed served throughout the USA on February 17^th.  The audits are expected to be completed within the next 2-3 months. We link here for more on this story.

This is a good time to review what you should do if you are served with a Notice of Inspection (NOI):

• Immediately contact Immigration Solutions and company management
• Employers are allowed by law 3 days notice to respond by producing the I-9 records of their active as well as terminated employees within a particular period of time

The NOI will be most probably be accompanied by a very invasive Document Subpoena that might ask for all of some of the below items:  

• A copy of your I-9 Policy and Procedures Statement or Manual
• I-9 forms for current employees hired after 11/6/1986
• I-9 forms for terminated employees within the required retention period
• Complete employee lists of current and terminated employees
• Quarterly Wage and hour reports
• Payroll Summaries
• SSA Mismatch correspondence
• E-Verify and/or SSNVS documents
• Business information such as:  Employer ID number, owner’s SSN/address, business license, etc.

We work with our clients to create compliant workforces, and now is the time to be proactive if you absolutely know that you have problems with your I-9 forms; and, by the way, most employers do.  We encourage you to be proactive and take action now before you pay the high price of being put in a position where your options have diminished.

We are happy to hear from you and are very flexible with our package of compliance services and solutions.  Our talented team is read to assist you with whatever you’d like to accomplish with your compliance programs.  Visit our I-9 Resource Center here.

Here’s another sad story from the restaurant industry. Snack Attack Deli, d/b/a  a Subway Restaurant franchise in Fayetteville North Carolina, has been neglecting filling out I-9 Employment Eligibility forms for several years to the tune of 108 I-9 violations producing a serious fine of some $111,078, as reported by the Department of Justice, Office of the Chief Administrative Hearing Officer (OCAHO) on February 11, 2011.  The Judge considered the small size of the company, the number of employees and their payroll and reduced the penalty down to $27,000 which was still difficult for the small franchise to handle.

Here’s the back story: Snack Attack produced 11 incomplete I-9 forms for 108 employees, current and mostly past employees, following the receipt of an NOI requesting I-9 forms for current and past employees for years 2006 through 2009 from ICE in early 2009.  The ICE auditor provided the owner with a copy of a sample I-9 form along with a copy of the I-9 Employer Handbook and told one of Snack Attack’s employees that if new forms were prepared, they should not be back dated.  Section 2 of the 11 I-9 forms that were produced were not filled out at all, and 7 of the 11 forms had been back dated  – including one for the restaurant owner.  Amazing- go figure!

ICE then issued a Notice of Intent to Fine in July 2009 stating that Snack Attack committed 108 I-9 violations including improper completion of the 11 forms, failing to complete I-9 forms for 97 employees.  Each violation carried a penalty of $1,028.50 for a total of $111,078.

Snack Attack alleged that the back dating was not their fault because it occurred in section 1 and that the owner had sold the business to another person, although there was no evidence to support his claim and so the judge issued civil penalties in the case.

The Judge wrote that failure to prepare an I-9 form is amongst the most serious of paperwork violations, in addition to not filling out the employer attestation in section 2.

It should be stated that there was no evidence of unauthorized workers and the 97 employees for whom no I-9’s were filled out, remains unresolved.  ICE’s position was that Snack Attack’s practices could very easily lead to the hiring of unauthorized workers.

We cannot stress enough that employers must be proactive and generate an I-9 form for all their employees and should catch these serious violations right now, particularly if you are in an industry such as food service, manufacturing/distribution, the garment industry, construction or the hospitality industry that are making headlines every week and creating media nightmares for employers

We also learn with this ruling that although fines are calculated based on regulatory criteria, there is some hope of relief based on a company’s size and business volume.  The question is, could there have had a much happier ending if Snack Attack would have retained the services of a competent attorney with a specialty in employer compliance issues to represent them during the audit?  We say unequivocally, “yes!”

For more information on employer compliance issues, please visit our I-9 Resource Center.