Following through on a campaign promise, Florida Governor Rick Scott signed four executive orders minutes after being sworn in, including one that requires all state agencies to use E-Verify, making it the first state to mandate E-Verify participation in 2011.  Florida joins a list of 13 other states that have mandatory E-Verify laws or executive orders in place.

According to a press release  from the governor’s office:

Executive Order No. 11-02 requires state agencies to use the E-Verify system to verify employment eligibility of state employees and contractors.

• All state agencies under the direction of the Governor must use the E-Verify system to check employment eligibility of their current and prospective employees.
• Requires state agencies under the direction of the Governor to include in all state contracts a requirement that contractors utilize the E-Verify system to verify the employment eligibility of:
  • all persons employed during the contract term by the contractor to perform employment duties within Florida; and
  • all persons (including subcontractors) assigned by the contractor to perform work pursuant to the contract with the state agency…

The Florida State Legislature, which convenes next week, is also expected to consider an Arizona-style immigration enforcement bill that would also require all employers in the state to use E-Verify. The bills are being drafted by Rep. Bill Snyder and Sen. Mike Bennett.  This is fast approaching the Arizona question again… Can the state trump the federal government on immigration requirements?

It is worth noting that, Rhode Island’s Governor, Lincoln Chafee, rescinded Rhode Island Executive Order 08-01 that required the state as well as contractors and vendors doing business with Rhode Island to register and use E-Verify for all new hires. Chafee called the use of E-Verify a “divisive issue.”

So, what does this mean going forward for Florida’s State Agencies and employers, in general? 

Prior to enrolling in E-Verify, you must undergo comprehensive I-9 training by skilled immigration counsel that maintains an active employer compliance practice so that your designated E-verify employees have a solid grounding in the law as it relates to the I-9 form and today’s complex issues concerning employment eligibility verification.  The most well intentioned employees make mistakes and, if you’re like most employers, 30-50% of your I-9 forms may have issues that put you at risk. Half of the companies audited by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) get fined $110,000 or more.

Employers must recognize that this can mean civil and criminal liability to both themselves and their employers for charging untrained and inexperienced employees with the employment verification process.

You’re probably thinking …this could never happen to me and my company…we’ve reviewed our I-9 forms, done a self-audit and put policies in place for the management of our employment verification program.  This thinking is understandable; however, untrained HR managers and assistants that try to correct or minimize their mistakes to save their jobs can lead to charges of document falsification, perjury and tampering. 

Plainly put, this complicated one-page, poorly designed I-9 form has a 70-page government instruction manual!  Performing a self-audit, with an untrained staff, can likely increase the possibility for penalties and fines.

Please have a look at our I-9 Employer Resource Center:  www.I-9Audits.com , contact our office to discuss your concerns and sign up to receive our news and information.