House Judiciary Committee holds Hearing Feb 27, 2013 on E-Verify to determine how it works and how it benefits American employers and workers

Areas of discussion were:

• Penalties for using E-Verify as a Pre-Screening Tool:  Doing so is abuse of the system and totally prohibited, although at this time there are no penalties for pre-screening candidates prior to the acceptance of a job offer.    The Monitoring and Compliance Unit of USCIS has indicated that they do indeed  investigate employer usage particularly when there are patterns of abuse, and can be referred to OSC.
• The panel discussed that Mandatory E-Verify as part of a CIR bill should not require employers to verify their entire workforce – but just their existing employees.
• Identity Fraud:  the Social Security Administration is working on a fix to identity fraud whereby one will be able to lock in their SS# to prevent multiple usage of numbers.  SSA anticipates that this feature will be ready to roll out by the end of the year.  As it stands now, a prospective employee can present fraudulent documents for the entire I-9 process for all 3 lists and be ‘work authorized’.

Further discussion ensured regarding the “phase in” process and whether or not the national usage mandate should become effective with the existing system while changes are implemented or wait until the system is further perfected.  Additional discussion took place around establishing an official procedure for those workers who have been terminated due to incorrect Final Non-Confirmation (FNC) notices so that they can rectify the incorrect data.

The following is a statement by Rep. Gutierrez:

“Today’s hearing is remarkable because we are talking about employment verification systems in their proper context.  We are discussing how to actually make them work and work for American workers with the right sorts of protections and appeals processes that make sure any errors are corrected in a timely manner.  And we are talking about electronic verification systems as part of a broader reform that legalizes the current workforce and allows for legal immigration in the future.”

There’s certainly more to track as discussions ensue, and we will keep you posted on this topic.